While on my way to El Fuego, the rightfully popular faux-Mexican burrito place, I paused to check out the menu at the Tuscany Cafe. I knew I’d end up spending a little bit more than if I’d continued on to El Fuego, but the curiosity of trying something new got the best of me.
Despite the name, the place looks like a coffee shop, and does not evoke anything from my travels in Italy, save for a few pre-made plastic wrapped sandwiches sitting out front. It was closer to Panera than Pompeii.
Many of the sandwiches look good. I almost went for the safe bet; a Chicken Waldorf number, but couldn’t decide. I asked the lady behind the counter what she recommended, and she went with the special: A Prosciutto and Brie Sandwich with Roasted Red Peppers and Pesto. I should have trusted my instinct and steered away– where did they get their prosciutto and brie from? I know the peppers and pesto are coming from a bottle– but I went with the suggestion.
It was promptly served on a flour-dusted, industrially-made ciabatta bread with Ruffles-style chips and a thin loser of a pickle. This special should be stricken from the record. The brie was domestic, cheap, and cut too thick. The heat of the microwave intensified that odd chlorine taste that brie can have. The prosciutto followed suit with the cheese, and was all salt and no pork; a far cry from DiBruno Brothers’ good stuff. This pig didn’t know Parma from Cleveland. (Ohh, snap!) The roasted red peppers must have come from a bottle, which is fine, but that bottle was stored in the fridge, so my peppers were cool and rather tasteless. Aaaand the pesto, oh, the pesto. Geeee-ROS (gross.) Real pesto is made with fresh basil, olive oil, toasted pine nuts, Parmigiano-Reggiano, and garlic. This tasted like McCormick dried herbs mixed with canola oil and garlic powder.
The best part is, I finished the sandwich. I left some lumps of brie and potato chips, but I still ate the damn thing. I wonder what would have happened if I brought the sandwich up after one bite and said, “This is gross. I’d like to trade it in for a new one.”
Despite this REALLY bad sandwich, I might go back to the Tuscany for the Chicken Waldorf. Or I’ll just pass by and eat at El Fuego.
For user reviews, check out the mixed ratings at Citysearch, the good ones at Yelp, and a write up in the City Paper.